The 20 Best Restaurants in New Berlin, Wisconsin

Zaffiro's Pizzeria - Ridge offers crisp, cracker-thin crust pizzas alongside casual American favorites such as grilled sandwiches, fries, and house-made snacks. Guests note flavorful specialty pizzas, including a creamy white chicken Alfredo option, and indulgent desserts like cream-filled donuts. The setting suits relaxed meals before or after a movie, with generally attentive, welcoming service.

Matty's Bar & Grille offers classic bar and grill favorites, from hearty burgers and patty melts to smoked wings and satisfying breakfasts. The interior feels welcoming, with a separate dining area and a spacious outdoor section featuring games, a stage, and large screens for sports. Attentive, upbeat staff contribute to the laid-back, social atmosphere.

Armeli's Restaurant & Pizzeria focuses on classic comfort dishes, with many guests highlighting its crisp-crust pizzas, flavorful sausage, and fish fry. Baked seafood options like blackened cod also appear on the menu, alongside simple appetizers and baked pastas. Attentive, efficient service and well-made cocktails contribute to a relaxed, welcoming dining experience.

Big Tuna is a casual sushi spot known for generous, flavorful rolls and consistently well-prepared sushi. Both dine-in and takeout guests note fast, attentive service. The compact dining room has a simple, unpretentious look, with a small selection of beer and wine. Signature specialty rolls like the Golden Dragon and Summer roll are popular choices.

Cleveland Pub & Grill is a lively sports bar offering hearty American pub favorites and a wide selection of beers on tap. Guests enjoy dishes such as baked cod, burgers, fajitas, and sandwiches while watching games on numerous TVs. The atmosphere is energetic and casual, with attentive, upbeat service and options for outdoor seating.

Rainbow Restaurant offers classic American comfort dishes in a small, welcoming setting. Diners highlight freshly prepared burgers, sandwiches, and hearty plates with homemade sides like mashed potatoes and coleslaw. All-day breakfast is popular, with generously sized pancakes and well-executed eggs Benedict. The clean dining room and personable service contribute to an easygoing, hometown feel.

Mustang Shelly's Roadhouse offers hearty pub-style fare in a casual, lively bar atmosphere. Guests highlight flavorful tacos on Thursdays, along with burgers, wings, soups, and other comfort dishes. Homemade chips with salsa and hot sauce add to the appeal, and the attentive staff contribute to the welcoming, energetic setting.

Señor Luna offers a broad Mexican menu featuring dishes such as sizzling fajitas, chile rellenos, and steak specialties, along with a traditional Friday fish fry. The dining room often feels lively and bustling, with prompt, helpful service. The restaurant also provides convenient catering with delivery, setup, and equipment pickup for events.

Cocina Real offers classic Mexican cuisine in a straightforward neighborhood setting, with a large menu that covers familiar favorites. Tableside guacamole and generously filled quesadillas stand out among the dishes, alongside well-liked steak options. Guests note consistently reliable food, prompt service, and a full bar featuring mezcal and other drinks, plus a seasonal outdoor patio for additional seating.

Texas Roadhouse is a lively American steakhouse known for hearty portions of grilled steaks, ribs, and classic comfort fare. Guests can view hand-cut steaks displayed at the entrance and enjoy warm rolls with cinnamon butter alongside salads and traditional sides like baked potatoes and coleslaw. The energetic atmosphere and upbeat music create a casual, bustling dining experience.

Buffalo Wild Wings is an establishment located in Wisconsin, USA, with a unique atmosphere that combines the functions of a sports bar and restaurant. It provides an environment where visitors can enjoy a variety of menu items while watching sports, creating an engaging experience for visitors.

Vitucci's Pizza is a family-run takeout and delivery spot known for thin-crust pies with flavorful sauces, including popular white-sauce options. The menu centers on a wide range of specialty pizzas, alongside calzones, garlic bread with cheese, lasagna, and sandwiches. Staff are described as friendly, and the space is kept very clean.