The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Flushing, New York

X-tra Cheese Pizza serves classic New York-style pies with a thin, sturdy crust, flavorful sauce, and fresh toppings. Run by a Sicilian family, it offers a welcoming, neighborhood feel whether you order whole pies or slices at the counter. Delivery is notably prompt, and side items like garlic knots are frequently praised for their freshness and taste.

Grace Pizza is a classic neighborhood pizzeria known for thin-crust New York-style slices and a selection of Italian favorites. Guests find cozy booths, sports photos, and a lively mix of families and locals. The menu extends beyond pizza to include pasta dishes and lightly breaded fried calamari, offering a familiar, comforting dining experience.

Graziella Pizza offers a mix of classic New York-style pies with generous, cheese-laden slices and traditional Italian entrées. Guests mention warm complimentary bread, pasta cooked al dente, and hearty chicken and veal dishes. The dining room feels more elegant than its modest exterior suggests, with greenery and music contributing to a pleasant setting. Attentive, accommodating service rounds out the experience.

Valentino's Pizzeria & Restaurant serves classic Italian-American cooking in a casual neighborhood setting. Guests find thin-crust pizzas, hearty sausage and pepper sandwiches, and well-cooked pastas alongside seafood dishes such as frutti di mare and Chilean sea bass, plus specialties like duck. Fresh salads and simple desserts round out the menu.

Amore Pizza serves classic New York–style pizza with a thin, crisp crust and a balance of melty mozzarella and homemade tomato sauce. Family-run with roots in a long-standing local pizzeria, it focuses on straightforward, well-executed slices. Both regular and Sicilian pies are praised for their consistent flavor and just-from-the-oven freshness.

Lucia Pizza serves classic New York–style slices with a thin, crisp yet chewy crust, balanced tomato sauce, and generous cheese. This compact, old-school pizzeria offers counter service with a few stools for those who choose to eat on the spot or take their slices to go. Fast, courteous service and consistently flavorful pizza make it a reliable neighborhood staple for a traditional slice.