The 20 Best Bagel Restaurants in New York

Lox of Bagels is an unassuming bagel shop known for its fresh bagels, hearty sandwiches, and flavored coffees. Guests mention a relaxed, comfortable space with plenty of seating. Even when it gets busy, the staff keeps the line moving and maintains a cheerful, welcoming attitude.

Bagel's & Bakes is a casual bakery café known for fresh bagels, hearty breakfast sandwiches, and a wide selection of baked goods. Guests highlight the range of bagel flavors and satisfying egg-and-cheese combinations, along with pastries such as cinnamon rolls. Coffee options and a simple counter-service setup create an easygoing stop for breakfast or a light lunch with sandwiches and salads.

Lox of Bagels and Moor is a casual bagel shop and café known for its fresh, house-made bagels and wide selection of cream cheeses. Guests choose from breakfast sandwiches, omelets, and lunch bagel sandwiches, along with baked goods such as cannoli. Hot coffee with various creamers and efficient, accommodating service create an easygoing, no-fuss stop just off the highway.

Water Street Bagel Co. specializes in freshly made bagels and inventive bagel sandwiches for breakfast and lunch. Guests choose from a wide range of bagel flavors and toppings, with staff offering thoughtful pairing suggestions. The self-serve coffee is noted as a strong complement to the food. A bustling wood-and-industrial space with both indoor and small outdoor seating creates an energetic café atmosphere.

Empire Bagels is a no-frills walk-up spot known for freshly baked New York–style bagels and bialys. The bagels are made on-site by the owner and draw steady lines of regulars, especially in the early morning. Simple coffee and spreads, including flavored cream cheeses, round out this classic neighborhood experience.

Bean Bagel Cafe is a casual spot known for its freshly made bagels and wide selection of cream cheese flavors. Guests appreciate the satisfying breakfast and lunch options, including egg sandwiches and omelets, along with hot coffee. The café offers a clean, unhurried setting where patrons can linger and enjoy conversation.

The Bagel Emporium of Armonk specializes in fresh bagels with a wide range of varieties and toppings. The recently updated space offers a straightforward spot to pick up breakfast or bring platters to meetings and gatherings. Known for its bagel and coffee catering, it serves both quick stops and larger group orders.

Bagel Master is a classic deli-style spot known for its fresh, warm bagels and generously filled bagel-and-lox combinations. The counter team works efficiently, even when lines stretch through the shop on busy days. Regulars appreciate the personable service, with staff often remembering familiar faces and favorite orders. A few tables offer a simple place to sit and enjoy coffee and a bite on site.

My Three Sons Bagels is a busy local spot known for large, well-made bagels with a satisfyingly chewy texture. Guests highlight the wide selection, from classic varieties to hearty breakfast sandwiches and deli-style fillings. Staff keep the operation moving efficiently, even with long lines, and the team is consistently courteous. The shop is noted for its cleanliness, with visible attention to maintaining a tidy space throughout the day.

110 Bagel Market & Bistro specializes in old-fashioned, hand-rolled bagels with a chewy texture and rich flavor. Guests find an extensive selection of deli sandwiches, house-made spreads such as strawberry cream cheese and lox spread, and baked sweets like crumb cake and brownies. The counter-service setup is complemented by indoor seating and attentive, efficient staff.