The 20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Orlando, Florida

Blaze Pizza specializes in build-your-own pizzas, allowing guests to choose their dough and a wide range of toppings before the pies are quickly baked to order. Diners note the thin, flavorful crust and the option for thoughtfully handled gluten-free pizzas, along with fresh salads. House-made flavored lemonades add a refreshing complement to the meal.

Flippers Pizzeria serves classic, freshly baked pizzas with a focus on rich flavor and satisfying textures. Soft, buttery breadsticks are a standout favorite, complemented by warm cookies for a sweet finish. Guests highlight consistently accommodating service, whether dining in or ordering for delivery, creating a dependable, casual spot for pizza cravings.

Stone Fired Pizza offers classic Italian-American comfort food, from stone-baked pizzas and calzones to pasta dishes and baked specialties. Guests highlight the flavorful pizza and popular pepperoni rolls, as well as efficient, attentive service that accommodates both small parties and large groups. The counter-order setup keeps the experience easygoing, with staff bringing freshly prepared dishes to the table.

NYPD Pizza Lake Cay serves New York–style pies with a well-liked crisp yet chewy crust and a balanced, not overly spicy sauce. Guests also mention flavorful chicken wings, garlic knots, and cheesecake. The dining room handles steady dine-in and takeout traffic, with prompt seating and quick delivery from the kitchen. Attentive, hardworking staff contribute to a smooth, casual dining experience.

Chuck E. Cheese offers a lively family destination combining casual pizza dining with a large selection of arcade games and simple rides for children of various ages. Guests mention helpful, organized staff who keep events running smoothly. Security measures at the entrance help ensure children leave only with their accompanying adults. Pizza, a salad bar, and beverages, including beer and wine, round out the experience.

Cicis Pizza offers a casual, family-friendly buffet with a wide variety of pizzas, including rotating specialty and dessert options such as Boston cream pizza. Guests note consistently hot, flavorful pies, along with wings, Italian-style selections, and self-serve beverages. The spacious dining area accommodates groups easily, and the attentive staff and hands-on owner contribute to a welcoming, well-run experience.

Red Oven Pizza Bakery specializes in stone-baked pizzas with notably light, flavorful dough that guests often share family-style. Pies such as Italian-inspired meat toppings are cooked in a visible oven, emphasizing a simple, straightforward approach. The atmosphere is energetic and casual, and the staff is described as attentive and helpful, even during busy periods.

Brooklyn Pizza specializes in handmade New York–style pies with a well-balanced crust, cheese, and sauce that appeal to classic pizza tastes. Generous cheese and freshly made dough are frequently noted, along with flavorful meat and vegetable toppings. Calzones are also available and receive positive mentions. The setting suits casual dine-in or takeout visits.

MOD Pizza offers a laid-back setting for made-to-order pizzas with both regular and gluten-free crusts. Guests highlight the flavorful combinations, from simple meat toppings to options with vegetables and garlic. Professional, attentive staff and efficient service make it a convenient choice for a quick, satisfying meal.

A Slice of New York Pizza serves classic New York–style pies with a thin, foldable crust and generous, well-balanced toppings. Large slices, garlic knots, salads, and other sides reflect a straightforward, neighborhood pizzeria menu. Service is typically quick and courteous, with many guests opting for takeout from this modest, locally favored spot.

Cicis Pizza offers an all-you-can-eat buffet of pizza, pasta, salad, and dessert with a wide variety of flavors regularly replenished. Guests mention options like Buffalo chicken and barbecue pizza, along with sweet cinnamon rolls and specialty dessert pizzas. The dining room is kept notably clean, and the lively, family-oriented atmosphere includes arcade-style games at the back.